Cultural Exploitation and Click Baiting: My Two Cents

25 74
Avatar for LykeLyca
3 years ago

There has been one trending issue in most social media today about Nas Daily, a vlogger famous for his 1-minute videos. Actually, I am a fan and I've been following an official page of him in Facebook. Yes, he is inspiring, but is he really true to his word on camera?

The issue started when this statement went viral.

"Some people are taking advantage of our culture. Please help us stop this disrespect to Apo Whang Od and the Butbut tribe" - Facebook post of Gracia Palicas

Gracia is the grandniece of Apo Whang Od. Apo is a 103 year old tattoo artist, she is amazingly unique for her tattoos and the way she  inked it in the human flesh is traditionally exceptional. Mind you, she is not just a tattoo artist, and her tattoos are not mere art. This is part of their indigenous tradition and all that enveloped her embodies the generation of the Kalinga ancestors in the Cordillera.

Photo: By Mawg64 - Own work, CC BY-SA 4.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=50374688

Right after that post, Nas Daily then showed video evidences about the agreement between Apo Whang Od and NasAcademy - an extension of Nas Daily, for the traditional tattoo art education for P700 (Philippine Peso). What would the National Commission for the Indigenous People (NCRP) have to say with this? I leave that to them, though I have read some posts from heritage lawyers that there are really lapses on the agreement.

Another Filipino broke her silence upon discovering Nas Daily issue, she is Louise, an entrepreneur working on a cocoa project. She made a lengthy post on her Facebook against Nas, and her experience about how arrogant and indifferent this vlogger off camera. The latter then replied publicly in social media, and another foreign vlogger too aired his side in support of Nas. Everyone talked and from everything they've said, I can gest something fishy condescendingly boiling into cultural exploitation and click baiting.

Just My Two Cents

So, this is just my opinion based on the story that all parties have had shared.

First, Nas Daily could've sought advice prior to any agreement with any heritage expert lawyers regarding the Philippines' value of culture, the indigenous people and the laws that surrounds it. Apo Whang Od, like all other tribes we have everywhere in the Philippines, are the backbones of our unique cultural community. We celebrate with them and respect each others authenticity. Thus, there is no equal amount to monetize this information. It is enough that a vlogger or anyone to showcase their story for the world to appreciate. But, to put up a Whang Od Academy in connection with Nas Academy learning portal for online content, and collect P700 from the learners to be educated about the tribes traditional art is just a sheer exploitation of the Kalinga heritage. That is really a bad move.

Second, if you noticed, some foreign video content creators love featuring stories about Filipinos and the Philippines for popularity. Must be because Filipinos love foreign validation that they're good, etc. They call it "Pinoy Baiting" because most of us spends our leisure time online thus we can make stuffs viral. This might be true, we can accept it. But to hear hurtful and discriminating words from this vlogger is not trustworthy to be treated with so much hospitality. So, all in all, I guess his venture to places and people is not really to inspire, but just to gain more views, more popularity and more money.

My final words...

Maybe this is the right time that we should be supporting our local online content creators. There are plenty of them that has been going around to places not just in the Philippines but also around the world to deliver us great and amazing stories.

Let us also stop validating our worth as a Filipino and as a person from the opinion of other nationalities. We should be proud in mind and in spirit, irregardless of anyone's opinion.

Finally, we are stronger as one community, let us protect the culture and tradition that made us unique up to this day.


The photo above is a traditional costume and dance from the Higaonon Tribe in the hinterland in Iligan City. We celebrated with them and with the Maranaw tribe during annual city festivals. Photo: by the author


I have posted some photos about our city's festival through this article:

Diyandi Festival - In My Lens


Lead Image, second image and content are all MINE. All Rights Reserved.

Plagiarized checked: 97% authentic, 3% from the quote. via Plagiarism Checker


I'm really surprised to see quite a number of new sponsors today and yesterday. Yay!

Thank you to my new sponsors @Eylz2021 , @Pichi28 , @CoquiCoin and @Jher0122, @ARTicLEE and @FarmGirl.

Thank you to my sponsors who recently renewed their sponsorship and to my readers for the heaps of support. Love, love, love!

Sponsors of LykeLyca
empty
empty
empty


16
$ 6.58
$ 5.71 from @TheRandomRewarder
$ 0.10 from @Jane
$ 0.10 from @gertu13
+ 13
Avatar for LykeLyca
3 years ago

Comments

I am not aware of these things. Hindi na kasi ako nagoopen Facebook. Pero napansin ko na na may mga foreign content creators na itotopic mga travel destinations in the Philippines and also food most especially Jollibee. Syempre ako naman curious ako of what they have to say about Jollibee. Agree ako na we Filipinos should support more of our local content creators before we support others.

$ 0.02
3 years ago

Hahah! That's us for foreign validation, foreigners knew that any pinoy would then flock commenting like "proud pinoy" etc. Vloggers would then love the attention and views resulting to Pinoy baiting in the next content.

$ 0.00
3 years ago

Pinoys spend time the most on social media so these foreign vloggers take advantage of it. He makes sense on his videos nman but this recent issue has showcased his true personality. 🤷‍♀️

$ 0.02
3 years ago

Ako din i used to follow Nas Daily pati si Project Nightfall. I even met them in person last 2019 sa SM MOA andami ding pumila. Napaka ironic pa nung time nasa MOA ako sa labas ng pila may malaking mural si Whang-od. 2 yrs. later ganito mangyayari. Sobrang dismayado ako

$ 0.02
3 years ago

Hello, interesting your post. I love to know the culture of other countries. I read recently that many countries are considering declaring cultural diversity as part of the common heritage of mankind. 100% agree, no culture should be considered above another. Greetings.

$ 0.02
3 years ago

I read Louise's response and her father's too.. i read na sinabi ni louise na he should check the farmers and sabi ni nas who cares about the farmers?

$ 0.00
3 years ago

Nas daily is a big company and they shoild done the right process regarding this matter and how sure we are that the agreement between them are truly understood by Apo Whang Od..There are so many lapses here. AnD I hope that the right process will be conducted and may our cultural heritage be preserve no matter what... It's ours not theirs..Our cultures are sacred and they are not to be tainted to take profit by any.

$ 0.02
3 years ago

Totoo yan. Apo's skill and traditional tattooing is part of the tribe. The agreement is null and void, because we have the law protecting them.

$ 0.00
3 years ago

That not only happens in the Philippines. In Venezuela, we also like foreign validation. And we value more what they say abroad instead of supporting our locals. That happens with influencers, artists, and in general in many areas. And the truth is that there are many people taking advantage of others to gain popularity. And as you say, we should support our culture and our content creators that speak with honesty.

$ 0.02
3 years ago

Sad that we have this mentality. There is really nothing wrong with it as long as no one is taking advantage of such weakness. But, nowadays there lots of content creators that would go high and below for money and popularity.

$ 0.00
3 years ago

The best yang si lola Wang-Od, doctora!

$ 0.02
3 years ago

Indeed, she is a treasure and a Philippine heritage that we should protect.

$ 0.00
3 years ago

Hndi ko pa ro napanood and I'm not familiar with Nas.. At true yan. Mga pinoy mas gusto pa ifollow yung foreign vloggers kesa sa local vloggers.. Kya tinitake advantage yun ng foreign vloggers. Prang lumalabas na madali tayo mauto. Lol Btw, my Father also came from Kalinga. But in a place called Apayao..

$ 0.02
3 years ago

Kya nga madam sabi nung Louise sa Facebook post nya na Nas even joke daw that he only needs to feature a Filipino clickable content and Filipinos would comment "brainless proud to be pinoy" daw na mga comments. Grabe mka insulto, he literally enjoys Pinoy Baiting for views/ comments.

$ 0.00
3 years ago

I love watching his videos too. Pero napansin ko lang, habang tumatagal parang ginagamit na sya for propaganda. May issue nga sa kanya being paid by Western countries to highlight negativity about certain countries. Tapos maraming nagalit sa kanya na Singaporeans. May issue rin sa kanya about Palestine. Kaya di na ko nanonood ng videos nya. Tapos nagmukhang preachy na sya na even other cultures ay nakwekwestyon nya.

$ 0.02
3 years ago

Yep. I have read one comment sa comment section nya that he have issues from other countries too. That's what happen if he became greedy for fame and money.

$ 0.00
3 years ago

Feeling ko lang talaga medyo mayabang sya. May napanood ako dati na video regarding North Korea, na positive naman. Akala ko si Nas, pero search ko, negative pala yung video ni Nas about North Korea. Nung nahanap ko yung tamang video, narealize ko na yung mga ibang vlogger minsan, parang propaganda rin. Dapat may both sides.

$ 0.00
3 years ago

"Let us also stop validating our worth as a Filipino and as a person from the opinion of other nationalities."

I couldn't agree more. We are worth it with or without their opinions. Narinig ko tung issue nato.

$ 0.02
3 years ago

What is more irritating are those die hard supporters of Nas calling our kind as fibble-minded for magnifying an issue. I was like seriously? I would rather be fibble-minded than ignorant of what these foreign bloggers do to our country.

$ 0.00
3 years ago

I agree with you that they should be proud of their culture. Although I belong to another culture I respect the culture of all countries without belittling any. and we must continue to sponsor and encourage. It is the only way for everyone to know and respect us.

$ 0.02
3 years ago

Indeed my friend we should respect each other's culture because these are sacred and important in most society.

$ 0.00
3 years ago

I guess that's what happens when the content creating starts concentrating on expanding business and reach. Nawawal na regard That is just sad.

I am yet to see the video showing the agreement.

$ 0.02
3 years ago

That's really true sis. I've seen a vid from Nas earlier that someone invested $11M for his company. That's really something he must be pressured to come up with more clickable contents and you're right disregarding the norms and laws of society.

$ 0.00
3 years ago

I see greediness from that vlogger, earning money from the expense of other.☹️. I admire and respect apo whang od. And your right she is one of our pillars🙂

$ 0.02
3 years ago

Indeed. Our uniqueness made us and we should be protecting it.

$ 0.00
3 years ago