Art History: The Benin Ivory Masks

24 24
Avatar for Ozzyy
Written by
3 years ago

Have you ever heard of the Benin Ivory Masks? Stick around let's get into the details.

INTRODUCTION

Benin is another ancient kingdom that is currently the capital city of Edo state of Nigeria. It was one of the oldest and most developed empires in that area of West Africa, having been formed at about the 11th Century A.D and it was annexed by the British in 1897.

Benin had its own art just like the Ife people, although the Benin Bronze works were done using the Lost Wax method which they learned from the people of Ife. However, Benin Art is semi-naturalistic, being more stylized than Ife Art. I guess the student does not always surpass the master. Here are some samples:

This was gotten from https://www.bbc.co.uk/bitesize/topics/zpvckqt/articles/z84fvcw. They are suspected to be from the pair of leopards that stood beside the Oba, or King, in his palace.
This =one is a depiction of the Europeans as seen by the Benin people. They maintained a healthy trade relationship with the Europeans until the Europeans switched up and decided to take their land by force.

But we aren't here to talk about Benin Art in general, but about a very special work. The Ivory Mask of the Queen Idia, the first Queen Mother, or Iyoba, of the 16th Century Benin Empire.

WHERE ARE THE MASKS?

In actuality, there were quite a few of these masks, I'm only sure of about three, and sadly, none of them are in Nigeria. You see, I'm about to take you down a bit of sad history here.

THE PUNITIVE EXPEDITION OF 1897

I might not be able to explain the whole thing in detail, but here's just a brief rundown of what went down.

As of 1862, Benin was one of the only Independent West African kingdoms and the Oba had a monopoly of trade in the area, and this irked the British, who described it as a place or barbarity and death because men and women slaves were offered as human sacrifices.

The British claimed they wanted to annex and take control of the empire for the progression of civilization, which in part was true, but they also had other ideas, like the collection of the precious Ivory located there.

The British tried again in 1892 to open up trade and ultimately bring Benin to subjugation by signing a treaty with Ovonramwen, who was the King, or Oba, at the time. This treaty justified Britain to exert greater influence over the empire. I don't know if OIvonramwen really understood what he was signing, the facts from letters between British administrators shows that Britain's move was more economic than humanitarian.

Oba Overamwen

Some sites cite that the Oba was forced to sign this treaty and that the British man who drafted it said the Benin Kingdom did so to gain 'protection' from the British, which was just outrageous.

Oba Ovonramwen doublecrossed - the treaty said 'free-trade', but he went on collecting customs duties. The Benin people were wary of the British and strengthened their military defenses when they discovered that the British had attacked and destroyed a close trading town.

An expedition was slated for 1896, but because Benin was vigilant and the Colonial Office disapproved of it, it was canceled. Still, between 1895-1896, efforts were made thrice to enforce the treaty, all to no avail.

But then, a trade embargo placed by Ovonramwen in 1996 was the final straw. This embargo closed trade along the Benin River, and it was caused by another group's refusal to pay tributes. The British then agitated for the embargo to be forcefully lifted and the Oba to be sent into exile, as he was an 'obstruction' to them.

The acting Consul-General, one Phillips, then decided to invade the Benin Kingdom, even when he had not received a go-ahead order from Britain. He moved in December 1996 with a total of 255 men, 250 of whom were African soldiers disguising as porters and musicians. The weapons were hidden in the luggage held by the 'porters'.

Funny enough, Phillips planned to pay for the expedition with the Ivory he was going to steal from the Oba's palace. He told the Oba he was coming to discuss trade and peace amongst other things.

However, neighboring towns went to tell the Oba that the British were bringing war. An emergency meeting was held, and the commander of the army decided they should launch a surprise attack on the British. Ovonramwen was unsure, citing that they should first allow the British to enter so that their purpose may be confirmed.

Whether this the right or wrong move, I cannot say, but the Army Commander ignored this decision and went on to attack the men at a community in January 1897. Since Phillips didn't expect an attack and did not know his activities were suspected in Benin, he was not ready, and their group was annihilated. Only two officers survived to return to Britain with the news.

In February 1897, the British returned with 1200 men and one goal - destruction of the Benin Empire. For over three days, they set fire to the kingdom, and this fire grew out of control. The Benin Kingdom had a wall which was, at one point, four times the length of the Great Wall of China. Little remains of that wall today.

A drawing of Benin City was made by a British officer in 1897. https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2016/mar/18/story-of-cities-5-benin-city-edo-nigeria-mighty-medieval-capital-lost-without-trace#:~:text=According%20to%20estimates%20by%20the,the%20Great%20Pyramid%20of%20Cheops%E2%80%9D.

After that, the looting of the Ivory pieces began, and the Idia masks were part of the artifacts looted. Today, there's very few left to identify the remains of this great Kingdom.

Oba Ovonramwen died in exile in the coastal area of Calabar in 1914, which was the same year the Northern and Southern protectorates were amalgamated to form the country that is now called Nigeria.

WHO WAS QUEEN MOTHER IDIA?

She was the mother of Oba Esigie. He had two conflicts - one during the ascension to the throne, and another, which was a war, during his time as King. She, however, was his advisor during this period and was known as the only woman who went to war. This made him give her the title of Iyoba or Queen Mother.

PROPERTIES OF THE MASK

Finally, you get to see the mask I've been talking about.

This one is currently at the British Museum in London

First, we have the marks above the orbits of her eyes - those are facial scarifications or tribal marks which was common to Benin women at the time.

The headdress and neck choker are from the coral royal beads. They were red in color, but today, the red cloth and dress are worn by all Edo people as they like during traditional festivities. Those beads were usually only worn by the Oba and his War Chief, but it was Queen Idia's special privilege to wear them.

The mask features the serene, calm look of a young woman, with the nostrils flared and the mouth thin, perhaps to indicate her firm, confident and bold nature. Idia was held in high esteem and reverence by the Oba and his people.

She also invented a Parrot-Head style of headdress, which is visible in the Bronze head, as seen here.

Also at the British Museum

The bronze heads were made after her death and mounted in front of altars and the Palace of the Queen Mother. The masks were worn by the Oba during certain ceremonies, and they usually contained amulets.

MODERN-DAY

Oba Akenzua II (1899 - 1978) began the movement for the return of the Benin Bronzes from Britain in 1936. Out of 3000 pieces, only 2 were returned during his reign. However, in the late 1930s, two coral crowns and a coral dress touted to belong to Ovonramwen were returned by one G. Miller, who was the son of one of the members of the expedition.

In 1977, The Festival of Arts and Culture or FESTAC was held in Lagos. The Nigerian Government tried to loan the mask from the British Museum but were refused. (I'm totally passed off at this moment).

They had to resort to a replica made by the sculptor and painter Erhabor Emokpae. Again, I'm totally pissed here.

The 2017 Movie Black Panther featured a replica of the artwork filmed at a place that was supposed to be the British Museum. You can watch it here at the exact timestamp.

Also, the Black Panther mask was created by a mix of different Benin Masks and artworks, and the movie also has different masks from other African cultures.

I hope you enjoyed this long narrative! Thanks!

Images sourced from Wikipedia unless designated otherwise. The picture of Oba Ovonramwen is from Brittanica.

EXTRA LINKS FOR FURTHER RESEARCH

https://www.omokoshaban.com/2019/12/10/after-117-years-a-stolen-statues-return-to-nigeria/

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Benin_ivory_mask#:~:text=The%20Benin%20ivory%20mask%20is,Art%20in%20New%20York%20City.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bronze_Head_of_Queen_Idia

6
$ 0.79
$ 0.74 from @TheRandomRewarder
$ 0.05 from @Hanzell
Sponsors of Ozzyy
empty
empty
empty
Avatar for Ozzyy
Written by
3 years ago

Comments

The British people are so selfish yet those relics aren't even theirs to begin with. Such a high and mighty air for stolen artifacts, really

$ 0.00
3 years ago

Really very frustrating. It made me very angry to see that they stole these things, kept some in their museums, and auctioned off the remaining, which have found the way to the US and Germany.

We were even reduced to having to loan them, and they still denied us access. It's just frustrating.

$ 0.00
3 years ago

I can understand that. That's what yhe do called conquerors do to the land they formerly dominated. They make that land feel as if it owes them those pieces. It's just sad. Things would have been better without the conquests and all, really

$ 0.00
3 years ago

If all they wanted to bring was civilization and religion, then fine. But that wasn't the case. They saw Africa as a place to make money from exploiting the locals. The British, French, and Portuguese did this a lot.

$ 0.00
3 years ago

Ohh so there were other countries that invaded too. Do they still do so even now? I've always liked african tapestries though :""

$ 0.00
3 years ago

I think Colonialism in the sense of the word does not exist anymore, although there are some so-called 'non-self-governing territories", 16 in number and comprising of 2 million people (as of 2012).

The French colonized Cameroun, Cote D'Ivoire (They are still named after the precious material which was being looted from them. Cote D' Ivoire means Ivory Coast.) and that's why most of these colonies still speak French today.

The same goes for Brazil, which was colonized by the Portuguese.

$ 0.00
3 years ago

Nahh i think it just shifted to the commercial sector and on what's most used. A country can colonize the other in a sense of where they'll get their raw materials from, the manufacturing and the market. It's in the for of contracts and treaties now that's why it went deeper than it did before

The thing with brazil i knew but wasn't sure about ivory coast. That's pretty fascinating new tidbit

$ 0.00
3 years ago

Yeah, it's basically a new name for the same act. Technicality does change things, doesn't it?

Cote D' Ivoire officially became a French colony in 1893 during something called the European Scramble for Africa. A most befitting name, don't you think?

$ 0.00
3 years ago

Okay I've read a bit and mygahd that's a hortible thing Europe did ;;-;; who made them supremacists oof

$ 0.00
3 years ago

It's disheartening reading that bit of history really. Then they would choose some locals and set as Warrant Chiefs to represent the British in Nigeria, thus pitting Brother against Brother.

$ 0.00
3 years ago

That's just downright petty but i guess a brother would trust the other but stillll! That's so low 🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬

$ 0.00
3 years ago

In the end, the Warrant Chiefs were won over to their side by gifts and other trash, like Cameras and Sugar, which was relatively new to us at the time.

There's this book called Things Fall Apart, I don't know if you've read it, but it describes what happened there. In the end, one of the villagers was brave enough to try to defy the British by engaging them in a fight and eventually beheading one, but none of the villagers backed him up.

Disappointed in what the village had become, he committed suicide.

$ 0.00
3 years ago

I'll read that book soon. I seriously need to calm my anxieties down. Seems like an interesting book and a different turn of events too

$ 0.00
3 years ago

You should. It's quite good.

$ 0.00
3 years ago

Not at all. It just makes the colonized country more dependent in a sense.

European scramble? In what sense though? I don't get that part ;;-;; might read on that in a bit

$ 0.00
3 years ago

European countries - France, England, and Portugal amongst others? were rushing to colonize African countries and exploit the mineral resources or other precious stuff found there - like the diamonds in South Africa and so on.

We literally became an 'All-You-Can-eat" Buffet for them.

$ 0.00
3 years ago

I can imagine. That's just sick. And it's sad that the Europeans got that greedy with what isn't even theirs. Now there's barely any diamonds left but i read somewhere that they're targetting gold ores and a few oil reserves still available there next?

$ 0.00
3 years ago

I still have to thank them for ending the barbaric customs that were in place - like the killing of twins, and human sacrifices.

But it was erroneous for them to say they were better. In 16th Century Benin, people did not have locks on their doors, and everyone felt safe. Meanwhile, London was said to be a place of murderers and thieves. Same story, different location.

I don't even know if there are more resources in Africa, I still believe there are, but Europe will still try to get more of our stuff. Maybe by tricky business deals, loans, and other means.

$ 0.00
3 years ago

Hmm.. i think the barbaric acts would have reduced over time with or without the external influence since people learn as the generations proceed. They just probably hastened the process. What would have been nice was if they shared more education and knowledge to the people but that's not the case. They just transferred their culture there in a way.

There are plenty! I had a Nigerian classmate and ge was damn proud of the resources you guys had. He had every right to be

$ 0.00
3 years ago

I was almost surprised that you saw a Nigerian in the Philippines, but then again, there's no well-known Nation that you won't find a Nigerian. We do love to Travel.

Well, I know for certain that religion changed the practices. If no new religion was introduced to us, we would have stuck to the old one. But my issue is that they should have brought the education and religion alone and then established legal, just trade options rather than using those two as a front for colonization.

It wasn't really as much about Christianity and Education as it was about the Money.

$ 0.00
3 years ago

Yes, I've met a few around here. I also have a nigerian neighbor but i rarely see him out. Just mostly in the afternoon when i walk the dogs

Lol those two were always the front. What better way to scare the people than through the threat of eternal damnation, right? People barely knew economics well enough back then so it woild have probably been a key player too in the Europeans way of conquest

$ 0.00
3 years ago

It is very interesting to know the history of your country through these great masks.

It is sad to know that the strongest always take advantage of the weak with their deceptions. There should be a law that forces looters to return what was stolen to their countries of origin.

$ 0.00
3 years ago

I feel the same way. I do not see any reason why the British Government refuses that these relics be returned. They have always used trickery and force to obtain the relics of Empires all over the world into their collection.

$ 0.00
3 years ago

And to think that they do it out of simple vanity. That they may be interested in the roots of other countries through their relics, but out of vanity. This is part of the pride of a culture and its heritage.

$ 0.00
3 years ago