The Psychology of Inconsistency: Why We Contradict Ourselves

This is the second part of the series of inconsistency. Visit my profile & articles to see the first part.

It is no doubt that inconsistency is a fascinating phenomenon. It's not uncommon to find individuals who hold opposing beliefs, make contradictory choices, or act in ways that seem entirely inconsistent with their stated values.

This inconsistency, often referred to as cognitive dissonance, plays a central role in psychology, influencing our thoughts, behaviors, and decision-making processes. This article delves into the psychology of inconsistency, exploring why we sometimes contradict ourselves and how this phenomenon shapes our lives.

Understanding Cognitive Dissonance

Cognitive dissonance is a concept that was first introduced by psychologist Leon Festinger in 1957. It refers to the discomfort or mental tension that arises when an individual holds conflicting beliefs, attitudes, or values. This discomfort often pushes people to resolve the inconsistency, leading to a variety of cognitive and behavioral adjustments.

The root of cognitive dissonance lies in the human desire for internal consistency. We inherently seek harmony between our beliefs, actions, and values. When inconsistency arises, it creates a state of psychological discomfort, prompting us to take steps to alleviate this discomfort.

The Sources of Inconsistency

There are several sources of inconsistency in our lives:

1. Evolutionary Heritage: Our minds have evolved over millions of years, and this evolutionary history sometimes leads to inconsistency. For example, our love for fatty, sugary foods might contradict our desire to be healthy. This conflict is a result of our evolutionary need to consume calorie-rich foods, which once meant survival.

2. Social Influences: Society's expectations and norms often influence our beliefs and behaviors. These external pressures can lead to inconsistency when we conform to societal expectations that may not align with our personal values.

3. Coping Mechanisms: In times of stress or emotional turmoil, we may adopt contradictory behaviors as coping mechanisms. For example, someone might say they want to be left alone while secretly yearning for support.

4. Limited Information: Our knowledge is always growing, and as we gain new information, our beliefs can change. This shift in beliefs may result in inconsistency with previously held opinions.

Coping with Inconsistency

Cognitive dissonance can be an uncomfortable state to endure. To resolve this internal tension, people employ various strategies:

1. Change Beliefs: Individuals may choose to modify their beliefs or attitudes to align with their actions. For example, a person who once enjoyed smoking but now wants to quit may adjust their belief about smoking's dangers.

2. Change Actions: Alternatively, someone may change their behaviors to match their existing beliefs or values. For instance, a person who values environmental conservation may start recycling more to reduce their inconsistency.

3. Add New Beliefs: Sometimes, individuals introduce new beliefs that help rationalize their inconsistency. This allows them to maintain their existing beliefs while incorporating new ones to reduce discomfort.

4. Seek Information: To alleviate cognitive dissonance, people often seek information that supports their existing beliefs, ignoring or dismissing contradictory evidence.

5. Minimize Importance: People may convince themselves that the inconsistency isn't important, reducing the need to resolve it. They may downplay the significance of the inconsistency to maintain their mental equilibrium.

The Impact of Inconsistency on Decision-Making

Inconsistency has a profound impact on our decision-making processes. We may find ourselves making choices that seem at odds with our long-term goals or values, and cognitive dissonance can be a driving force behind such decisions. For example:

1. Consumer Choices: People may buy products or engage in behaviors that contradict their values, such as choosing convenience over sustainability or selecting unhealthy foods despite valuing their health.

2. Political Beliefs: In the realm of politics, cognitive dissonance can lead individuals to hold conflicting political beliefs, sometimes due to social pressures or party loyalty.

3. Relationships: Inconsistency can play a significant role in relationships, leading to mixed signals, ambivalence, or conflicts. Someone may say they value honesty while being dishonest in a relationship, creating a contradiction.

4. Career Decisions: In the workplace, inconsistency can affect career choices. For example, someone might choose a job they don't enjoy because it pays well, contradicting their desire for job satisfaction.

Embracing Self-Reflection

To better understand and manage inconsistency in our lives, self-reflection is a valuable tool. Here are some steps to consider:

1. Identify Inconsistencies: Start by recognizing areas in your life where inconsistency may be present. Are there situations where your beliefs, actions, or values seem contradictory?

2. Examine the Source: Explore why these inconsistencies exist. Are they driven by societal pressures, personal coping mechanisms, or a lack of information?

3. Prioritize Values: Reflect on your core values and beliefs. What matters most to you? This can help you determine which inconsistencies are most important to address.

4. Seek Resolution: Decide whether you want to resolve these inconsistencies or accept them. Some may be worth addressing, while others might not significantly impact your well-being.

5. Embrace Growth: Understand that change is a part of life. As you gain new information and experiences, your beliefs and values may evolve, leading to a natural inconsistency.

Inconsistency is a complex psychological phenomenon deeply rooted in the human experience. It is both a source of discomfort and a catalyst for growth and change. By understanding the psychology of inconsistency and learning how to navigate it, we can lead more authentic, self-aware lives, ultimately reducing the dissonance that sometimes clouds our decisions and actions.

Thanks for reading guys. I'll see you at the next one. Don't forget to like, share, comment and subscribe for more interesting articles like the one you just read.

Peace, love & light.