Believing the Atomic Bomb Was Necessary Is the Same as Believing the Holocaust Was Necessary

Regardless of the fact that military brass and other experts on the matter historically said it was unnecessary, and that the Japanese government's representatives were attempting surrender to no avail, some individuals still wish to maintain "We'd all be speaking German right now if those bombs hadn't been dropped!" Or that "More lives would have been lost had we not ended the war." Of course that we doesn't actually mean them, personally. They didn't lift a finger to change things either way. Most of these folks weren't even born yet.

Before diving right into my justification and rationale for the provocative headline, let's not forget the gruesome firebombings that occurred throughout Japan during WWII as well, which are almost never discussed, but included the single most destructive air raid in history — in Tokyo — engulfing 10,000 acres in flames, killing 100,000 people, and leaving an estimated one million homeless. This was in one night.

But I'll get to the point. The following is why belief in the so-called "necessity" of the atomic bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki is qualitatively the same as the belief that Hitler's mass destruction of innocent individuals was "necessary":

Both massacres were done under the pretext of being for the "greater good," and both had legions of nationalists supporting them in the name of freedom, prosperity, and progress.

Both destroyed the lives of non-violent, innocent individuals caught by happenstance in the middle of a massive, violent, political power struggle.

Presuming the destruction or violation of even a single non-violent individual for the "greater good" is necessary is a logically untenable (where sustained peace is the end value), immoral, and evil presumption without basis in objective reality. As all collectives are by necessity made of individuals, to systematically compromise the safety of any one non-violent individual is to compromise the foundation and safety of that collective society as a whole. Even so-called American values become immediately unsustainable under this logical and morally depraved myopia. Bombing one's way to peace, in other words, is absurd and unsustainable where minimal violent conflict is the end goal.

Those who believe in the necessity of the atom bombs being dropped on Japan, are simply cheering for the other side in a soccer match between two murderous, psychopathic entities. Cheering for either is committing the same idiot oversight. Whether it be for Hitler's golden vision for a German motherland of peace, prosperity, and power (you realize he didn't come to power saying he was going to exterminate a bunch of people, right?) Or for Truman's rhetoric about bringing peace and prosperity to the world by incinerating hundreds of thousands of individual lives caught in the crossfire of war.

Let's stop cheering, open our eyes, and see:

-GWS